amiga-news DEUTSCHE VERSION
.
Links| Forums| Comments| Report news
.
Chat| Polls| Newsticker| Archive
.

[Login] [Register] [Forgot your password?]

< Next messagePrior message >
14.Sep.2002
Oliver Hummel/Amithlon ML (ANF)


Statement by Bernd Meyer regarding the upcoming AmithlonXL package
According to Bernd Meyer it is unclear to him for now whether the yesterday by VMC on amiga-news.de announced AmithlonXL is just an "add on" CD similar to the Elbox Multimedia CD or in fact a full emulator package.

In case that it should be a full emulator package, Bernd Meyer points out in his statement that VMC/Haage&Partner wouldn't have any license for the distribution of those parts of Amithlon that are basing on his work (e.g. optimized Jit), furtheron both sides don't have any license by Amiga Inc. for the distribution of the needed Kickstart/Workbench files.

Additionally he won't make future updates meant for users of the original Amithlon available for an AmithlonXL package.

Editorial comment:
We all cannot judge which of both sides (Bernd Meyer vs. VMC/H&P) is right or wrong here resp. respectively which of the sides is misinterpreting the concluded contracts. In any case it is clear that there are obviously two very different points of view existing. We ask therefore our readers to be very objective in possible comments and to do without any recriminations and insults.

Here the complete statement:

              Regarding so-called "AmithlonXL"
              ================================

* I have absolutely no knowledge of this "product" beyond that which is
  publicly available on Amiga news sites.

* I am not in any way involved with this "product".

* At the current time, it is unclear (to me at least) whether this is
  supposed to be an add-on for existing Amithlon users (akin to the
  Elbox "Multimedia CD", simply offering a collection of new drivers),
  or whether it is meant to be something including emulator executable
  and ROM files.

* If it is just a collection of drivers, I have no problem with it.
  About bloody time, I'd say.

* If, however, someone is planning to distribute my IP (as contained in the
  emulator executable), I'd strongly advise to reconsider, as neither
  Harald Frank nor Haage&Partner have any license to do so. Furthermore,
  to the best of my knowledge, neither of those parties have a license
  from Amiga Inc for the distribution of kickstart images. 

* The announcements on www.amiga-news.de and www.ann.lu also talked about
  the demo machine being equipped with a Dual Head Matrox card. I sincerely
  hope that this is not an indication that my multi-head capable
  gfx driver for Amithlon is considered or presented as part of
  "AmithlonXL", as the license attached to that driver quite clearly
  prohibits it.

* Let me also reiterate that of the contents of the amithlon_contrib*
  packages released by me, ONLY the parts under the GPL are available
  for inclusion with any Harald Frank or H&P product, and that inclusion
  of those parts would require the strict adherence to the licensing
  terms of the GPL.
  
* Obviously, I won't be supporting an "AmithlonXL" which violates my
  intellectual property rights in any way. This would certainly include making
  sure that the proprietary parts of any further contrib packages I release 
  for the users of the original Amithlon would not work with such an
  "AmithlonXL". Personally, I despise crap like that, but what can I do?

* I would finally like to ask everyone to recognize that at the current
  time, to the best of my knowledge "AmithlonXL" is purely a Harald
  Frank idea --- I have yet to see a single word about it from Haage&Partner.
  So please don't abuse H&P over something they, for all I know, might not 
  even know about.


       Bernd Meyer, 

       Main Amithlon programmer                                                  

(ps) (Translation: wk)

[News message: 14. Sep. 2002, 13:26] [Comments: 2 - 16. Sep. 2002, 03:43]
[Send via e-mail]  [Print version]  [ASCII version]
< Next messagePrior message >

.
Masthead | Privacy policy | Netiquette | Advertising | Contact
Copyright © 1998-2024 by amiga-news.de - all rights reserved.
.